2007 Ground Water Summit

Monday, April 30, 2007 : 1:00 p.m.

Ethanol Replacement of Fuel Oxygenates: Inconsistency of Public Policy and Science

Donald E. Jones, CGWP and Erin M. Glennon, Quality Environmental Solutions

Despite intense lobbying by the petroleum industry, the recently enacted Energy Policy Act of 2005 did not include a provision to protect the industry from litigation for ground-water contamination due to the fuel oxygenate methyl tert-butyl ether (MTBE).  Coupled with the ban of MTBE in several states, the writing was on the wall – MTBE had to be replaced.

The possible switch in the Mid-Atlantic States to ethanol was rumored in February 2006.  By the end of May the switch was complete, except for a few pockets of resistance.  The rapid changeover seems to have occurred with little discussion of the possible short and long-term environmental impacts of the switch to ethanol.  The bio fuels production and corn grower lobbies had been working long and hard on the issue.  The ground-water industry concerns did not reach the level of public or legislative concern.The potential ground-water impacts associated with the use of ethanol may be greater than those with MTBE.  The authors will discuss the current environmental concerns and present field data associated with the use of ethanol at several locations.  The primary concerns with ethanol are product compatibility with storage and dispensing systems, ethanol effects on previous and new gasoline releases, and laboratory sampling procedures and accuracy.  The goal of the paper is to demonstrate how public policy was shaped and implemented relatively rapidly with little concern for the potential negative impacts to ground-water users.  It appears that public policy concerning ethanol has followed the previous path of MTBE acceptance as the fuel oxygenate of choice.  Will ethanol use follow a similar path?  Will future releases and litigation force the petroleum industry and regulators to seek another alternative? Technical and public policy discussions concerning the use of ethanol need to continue in concert with field data and demonstrations.

Donald E. Jones, CGWP, Quality Environmental Solutions Senior professional with more than 25 years technical, sales, project, and business management experience in private consulting business. Founder of Quality Environmental Solutions, Inc. in 1992. Technical specialties include environmental site assessments, hydrogeologic evaluations, remedial system design and implementation, permit strategy development, and technical training. Experience includes management of projects involving assessment and remediation of ground water contaminated by petroleum hydrocarbons and industrial chemicals.

Erin M. Glennon, Quality Environmental Solutions Ms. Glennon has numerous years experience with retail petroleum facilities including regulatory oversight of underground storage tank system installation, upgrade, and removal; environmental site assessments; technical report preparation; well installation; field data collection; and, residential community and regulatory agency interface. Ms. Glennon is a Maryland-certified UST system third-party inspector. Ms. Glennon previously worked as a contract professional for BP as an Environmental Business Manager. Her responsibilities included oversight of several consulting firms and coordination of real estate transactions within the company and externally.


The 2007 Ground Water Summit